Mieux Donner

Co2: the concentration of carbon dioxide and its dangers

Vue aérienne de réacteurs produisant des émissions
Picture of Camille Berger

Camille Berger

Chef de Projet
Temps de lecture : 5 min.

Why CO2 is bad: a discreet gas with massive effects

Excess Co2 increases the planet’s temperature by preventing too much infrared radiation from escaping back into space. It acidifies the oceans and, in high concentrations, interferes with the body by acidifying and dilating blood and brain fluids.

But what exactly is this gas? It is a colourless, odourless gas that is naturally present in the air we breathe, but when it reaches significant quantities, it can have serious consequences for the environment and human health. Carbon dioxide (CO₂), also known as carbon dioxide or carbon dioxide anhydride, is at the heart of today’s climate and health challenges. Invisible but ubiquitous, this greenhouse gas plays a key role in global warming, indoor air quality and even health in the workplace.

Combating CO2

Supporting specialist organisations can reduce CO2 emissions on a large scale. At Mieux Donner, we identify organisations that are tackling the problem with evidence, reviewed by rigorous evaluators.

Clean Air Task Force is investing in the regulation of super-heating gases such as methane, as well as under-invested but promising technologies to replace our polluting energy sources, such as super hot rock geothermal energy. A pioneer in this field, the CATF is regularly involved in major legislation around the world, such as the Methane Reduction Act in Europe and theInflation Reduction Act in the United States.

Pictogramme représentant la terre et un thermomètre

Give 100 euros to the CATF and reduce 100 tonnes of carbon [1]
= more emissions than 125 transatlantic flights [2].

The Good Food Institute works to replace meat products with plant-based alternatives, reducing the carbon dioxide emissions associated with livestock farming, as well as water and land use. The GFI supports the research and marketing of all types of alternative proteins.

Pictogramme représentant la terre et un thermomètre

100 donated to GFI avoids 33 tonnes of carbon emissions [2] = roughly the equivalent of 20 transatlantic flights [4].

An essential gas in its natural state, but now a pollutant

Carbon dioxide is made up of one carbon molecule and two oxygen molecules. It is naturally present in the atmosphere, produced in particular by the respiration of living organisms and absorbed by plants during photosynthesis. In this context, its presence in very minute doses is beneficial: this is the principle of the natural greenhouse effect, which maintains a stable temperature on Earth.

But this fragile natural balance has been disturbed. Since the industrial era, carbon dioxide emissions have soared from around 280 parts per million (ppm) to over 400 ppm today. This increase in the concentration of CO2 in the air is due to human activities, in particular the burning of fossil fuels (coal, oil, natural gas), deforestation, certain agricultural practices and intensive livestock farming.

Why CO₂ is bad: a critical level for health and safety

In its natural state, Co2 is only dangerous to health in high concentrations, which is rare. But if it is present in large quantities, it becomes harmful. At concentrations of 2% or more in the air (i.e. 20,000 ppm), it can cause an increase in breathing rate, headaches and even loss of consciousness.

In classrooms, offices or the air inside buildings, poor ventilation can lead to a higher concentration of carbon dioxide than in the air outside, as it is produced when living beings breathe. This pollution affects human health, reduces productivity, disrupts sleep and raises questions about health in the workplace.

CO2 in the atmosphere is therefore a pollutant that needs to be monitored closely, like a conventional pollutant such as carbon monoxide, although it is non-toxic in small doses.

CO₂ and global warming: emissions with global effects

CO₂ emits heat by trapping infrared radiation in the atmosphere, accelerating global warming. This dynamic is amplified by the increase in the concentration of CO₂ in the atmosphere, particularly when organic materials such as fossil fuels are burnt, or even when wood is burnt. This process emits CO2 in large quantities. Even though the earth has its own carbon cycle, our emissions far exceed the natural rate of absorption.

The damage caused is already visible: melting glaciers, rising sea levels, ocean acidification, disappearing ecosystems and extreme weather events.

How can we reduce CO₂ emissions?

Major differences in impact

Lifestyle changes may at first sight seem important for preserving the climate. In this category, giving up flying and switching to a plant-based diet are among the most effective interventions. However, donating to the charities with the biggest impact is still the best way to avoid carbon emissions:

If you’re looking to direct your giving to make the biggest impact, Mieux Donner can help guide you. We also provide personalised advice for individuals and businesses.

Where did all this CO₂ come from?

Natural sources include respiration, volcanoes and the decomposition of organic matter. But it is human sources – industry, transport, agriculture – that cause the runaway emissions. For example, burning wood or coal directly releases carbon dioxide into the air. Livestock farming activities, via manure or soil transformation, also emit CO₂.

The other greenhouse gases are also of concern (such as methane or nitrous oxide), although CO₂ remains the main contributor in significant quantities in the air, as they can sometimes have a greater warming potential. This is why we often speak of “equivalent tonnes of CO2”, to take all these different gases into account.

In a nutshell

CO₂ in the atmosphere is a major pollutant today. Resulting from combustion, it affects our health, the air we breathe and the global climate. We urgently need to take action to reduce CO₂ emissions – even if reviewing our habits will be inevitable, supporting high-impact initiatives remains our best tool for doing so.

Notes and references

[1] Justification of our estimate of one tonne of carbon avoided per euro donated to the Clean Air Task Force (CATF)

 

It is difficult to put a precise figure on the tonnes of carbon avoided through advocacy work, but the most rigorous assessment available from CATF gives us confidence that 1 tonne of carbon avoided per euro spent is a conservative estimate and not an overestimation of their impact.

 

Here is our justification for estimating CATF’s impact:

(Note: we use a conservative conversion rate of 1 USD: 1 EURO in our impact calculations).

  • Founders Pledge, a leading charity evaluator of climate charities, has conducted an in-depth analysis of CATF. Their assessment estimated the cost of reducing CO2e emissions to be between £0.10 and £1. For the full assumptions and reasons why £1 per tonne is considered a conservative and acceptable estimate, please see page 116 onwards of their report. Here is an excerpt from page 119 of the report: ‘While this estimate will clearly be wrong, the assumptions are chosen such that it is likely that this estimate is too conservative — it is entirely possible that the actual effectiveness is 10x or 100x higher than this estimate, while it seems much less likely that the estimate is too optimistic.’ Of course, not every CATF project is as impactful as their work on 45Q, and the conservative estimate for this project should not be taken as a general assessment of their work. It is more reasonable to assume that the average project is 10x less effective than this project, giving a cost of £0.75/tCO2e as a conservative estimate.”
  • Although the Founders Pledge report dates from November 2021, CATF has continued to achieve significant political successes since then, such as the EU methane regulation and the Inflation Reduction Act. These achievements demonstrate sustained impact, leading us to believe that CATF’s effectiveness remains consistent with the findings of the Founders Pledge report — and even higher, given the considerable scale of these two policies.

  • CATF is one of Giving Green’s top charitable recommendations for 2025. Their benchmark for the most effective charities is 1 tonne of carbon avoided per £1 donated.

  • The estimate of one tonne per pound is also shared by our German colleagues, Effektiv Spenden, the most successful and respected effective giving initiative in continental Europe.(They have in-house researchers who independently verify charities’ impact estimates.)

[2] Not the End of the World, Hannah Ritchie (2024)

Each transatlantic return flight emits an average of 1.6 tonnes of CO2 equivalent, so a one-way flight emits 0.8 tonnes of carbon.

 

[3] The Good Food Institute, Deep Dive (Giving Green) [Accessed 11/07/2024].

Giving Green’s best estimate for GFI’s effectiveness is $2.98 per metric tonne of CO2 equivalent pending. (We have used a conservative conversion of $2.98: €3 for our impact calculation).

 

[4] Not the end of the world, Hannah Ritchie (2024)

Each transatlantic flight emits an average of 1.6 tonnes of CO2.

You might also want to read...

Valeur d’une vie en France
Romain Barbe

What is the cost of a human life?

Human life is precious. It is natural to want to mobilise all our resources to save a life, even if it only prolongs a life by a week. But what happens when other people are also in danger, and our resources are not enough to help them all? As a society, we face practical limits that force us to make difficult decisions.

Read More »
Tags :