Rédaction chez Mieux Donner
Temps de lecture : 7 min.
When we think of planetary atmospheres, we immediately think of the vast gaseous envelopes that surround the planets of the Solar System, such as Venus, Mars and Jupiter. But these atmospheres are more than just layers of gas floating in space: they influence temperature, climate and the very possibility of supporting life. By understanding how these atmospheres evolve, we can gain valuable clues about the future of our own planet, Earth.
Today, space exploration and scientific missions are enabling us to compare our Earth’s atmosphere with those of Mars, Venus or Titan, and the conclusions are clear: our climate is fragile and can tip over under the effect of greenhouse gases and human activities. How can the other atmospheres of the Solar System help us avoid the worst?
Venus and Earth were once very similar in size, composition and position relative to the Sun. Today, however, Venus is an infernal furnace, with a surface temperature of 467°C – enough to make the mercury hot enough to melt lead. Atmospheric pressure is almost 100 times higher than on Earth. Why is this? Its orbit is not to blame: it is practically included in the habitable zone. The explanation can be summed up in four words: the uncontrolled greenhouse effect.
Venus has an atmosphere made up mainly of carbon dioxide (96%), a gas that traps heat from the sun’s rays. The surface of Venus is subject to constant volcanism. Clouds of sulphuric acid prevent heat from escaping, turning the planet into a permanent oven. What’s fascinating and worrying is that this phenomenon could theoretically happen to the Earth if we don’t get our own CO₂ emissions under control.
Unlike Venus, Mars is an icy planet, unlike Pluto, which owes its freezing temperatures to its distance from the Sun. The problem is that it has a very thin atmosphere, made up of 95% CO₂, but too thin to retain heat. 3.5 billion years ago, the Red Planet had a denser atmosphere, liquid water and possibly conditions favourable to life, but the solar wind, combined with the loss of the Martian magnetic field, gradually swept away the atmosphere, leaving an arid and cold planet. The surface of Mars is now hostile to the development of life, bombarded by ultraviolet radiation.
Mars is a reminder of just how precious and fragile our planet’s atmosphere is: a planet can lose its climatic balance and become inhospitable over relatively short timescales. Venus and Mars are therefore mirrors of our future: one shows what happens when an atmosphere is too thick and saturated with CO₂, the other when it disappears.
Gas giant planets like Jupiter and Saturn have no solid surface. Their atmospheres are mainly made up of hydrogen and helium, with traces of ammonia and methane. But what attracts scientists’ attention about the gaseous planets are their monstrous storms, such as Jupiter’s famous Red Spot, a gigantic anticyclone that has been active for more than 300 years.
These extreme phenomena remind us that the Earth’s atmosphere is also dynamic and sensitive to climate change. The rise in temperature caused by greenhouse gases could intensify extreme weather events on Earth, like the storms on Jupiter.
Titan, Saturn’s largest satellite, is a fascinating exception. It has a dense, hazy atmosphere, mainly made up of nitrogen, like the Earth. It also contains methane, which plays the role of terrestrial CO₂ in maintaining a relatively stable climate.
On Titan, methane forms clouds, rain and liquid lakes, but at -180°C. This shows that atmospheres can evolve differently depending on initial conditions. The Cassini-Huygens mission revealed that Titan has a methane cycle similar to the water cycle on Earth. Space probes like Cassini give us an alternative model of the climate, helping us to understand the effect of greenhouse gases on Earth.
The study of other atmospheres in the Solar System is not just a scientific curiosity: it is a matter of urgency for our own planet. Space missions, such as those by NASA and ESA, are helping us to better understand :
Thanks to these studies, we can improve our climate models, anticipate future changes and better combat global warming.
Several space missions are now helping climatologists to gain a better understanding of the Earth’s past and future:
The aim is clear: to better understand extraterrestrial atmospheres in order to better protect our own.
By studying the atmospheres of other planets, we realise that our own climate is rare and precious. Unlike Mars or Venus, we still have the opportunity to act. Scientists are categorical: reducing CO₂ emissions is essential.
Mieux Donner recommends a number of high-impact associations fighting global warming:
Clean Air Task Force: This organisation effectively combats climate change through public policy and technological innovation. In particular, they have made a major contribution to the European regulation of methane, a gas with a powerful greenhouse effect.
Good Food Institute: This organisation is dedicated to innovation in alternative proteins, a much lower-emission alternative to conventional meat.
Every well-placed donation has a real impact. If we want to prevent the Earth one day resembling Venus or Mars and preserve our oxygen, we must act now.
Space exploration gives us a unique insight into the evolution of atmospheres and climates. Mars shows us what happens when an atmosphere is lost, Venus what happens when it becomes too dense in CO₂.
We have a unique opportunity to learn from these worlds to preserve our own. Donner Better helps you take effective action to protect the Earth’s atmosphere.
Ready to make a difference? Discover our recommended associations and help preserve the Earth’s atmosphere.
Is deciding from London or Paris who needs help and how a form of colonialism? This article examines what the critique gets right, where it goes wrong, and what effective giving does concretely differently — including its own blind spots.
Scared Straight won an Oscar and increased delinquency. Open Philanthropy invested $130 million in criminal justice reform — then changed course. Romain Barbe examines what the evidence actually says, and where your money can do the most good.
31 confirmed deaths, or nearly a million? Romain Barbe examines what the data actually say about Chernobyl’s human toll — and why the fear it generated may have killed far more than the radiation itself.
Good intentions, bad outcomes. Romain Barbe examines the tension between moral consistency and real-world impact — using sex work laws as a case study for how to choose the fights that actually work.
GiveDirectly sends $1,000 directly to households in extreme poverty — no conditions, no intermediaries. What the research shows, how GiveWell rates the programme, and why French tax relief isn’t available.
What is systemic change, and how do you tell a rigorous systemic charity from an ambitious-sounding one? A practical guide for donors, grounded in evidence and documented examples.
